• Free US Shipping Over $100
  • Account
  • Cart (0)
  • Checkout
Artisan Crafted Christian Jewelry and Inspirational Religious Gifts Designed to Encourage Your Spirit and Uplift Your Heart
Artisan Crafted Christian Jewelry and Inspirational Religious Gifts Designed to Encourage Your Spirit and Uplift Your Heart
  • Home
  • Shop Jewelry 
    • Custom Engraved
    • Necklaces 
      • 14k Gold
      • Sterling Silver
      • Fine Pewter
    • Bracelets 
      • Sterling & 14k Gold
      • Gold Brass
      • Mixed Media
    • Charms & Chains
    • Earrings & Rings
    • Men's Jewelry
    • Children's Jewelry
    • Handwriting Jewelry
  • Shop Gifts 
    • Personalized Gifts
    • Olive Wood Crosses & Hearts
    • Journals & Notepads
    • Art Prints
    • Keyrings
    • Polishing Cloths
  • Gift Guides 
    • Shop By Occasion 
      • Baptism
      • First Communion
      • Confirmation
      • Easter
      • Graduation
      • Mother's Day
      • Father's Day
      • Birth & Adoption
      • Memorial
      • Anniversary
      • Recovery/Serenity
      • Christmas
      • Valentine's Day
    • Shop By Theme 
      • Appreciation
      • Encouragement
      • Friendship
      • Strength & Healing
      • Mustard Seed Faith
      • Fruit of the Spirit
      • Guardian Angel
      • Holy Spirit Dove
      • Lion of Judah
      • Hymns of Praise
      • Inspired by Nature
      • From the Heart
      • Celtic Symbols
      • Holy Land
    • Shop By Verse 
      • 1 Corinthians 13
      • Colossians 3:12
      • Ephesians 3:20
      • Esther 4:14
      • Galatians 5:22
      • Hebrews 6:19
      • Isaiah 40:31
      • Jeremiah 29:11
      • John 3:16
      • Joshua 1:9
      • Luke 1:45
      • Luke 18:1
      • Matthew 5:16
      • Matthew 17:20
      • Matthew 19:26
      • Matthew 28:20
      • Micah 6:8
      • Numbers 6:24-26
      • Philippians 4:13
      • Proverbs 3:5
      • Proverbs 31
      • Psalm 23
      • Psalm 46:10
      • Psalm 91:4
      • Song of Solomon 6:3
    • Shop By Recipient 
      • Mom
      • Dad
      • Little Ones
      • Teens
      • Teachers
      • Sweethearts
    • Personalized Gifts
    • Current Best-Sellers
    • Gifts Under $20
  • Connect/FAQs 
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • FAQs
    • Shipping Info
    • Return Policy
    • Customer Reviews
    • Newsletter Sign-Up
    • Blog Posts
What's new? Here's the latest from Clothed with Truth...

How to Clean and Protect Your Fine Pewter Jewelry

Fine Pewter Jewelry Made in the USA Available at Clothed with Truth

Fine pewter jewelry is a timeless treasure, prized for its unique charm, understated elegance, and lustrous appeal. Whether you've inherited an heirloom piece from your great-grandmother or just acquired a brand new favorite necklace from our collection here at Clothed with Truth, knowing how to properly clean and care for your pewter jewelry is essential to ensure it remains as beautiful as the day you first laid eyes on it. In this guide, we'll take you through the steps to keep your pewter jewelry radiant for years to come. 

First things first...before we delve into our expert tips for cleaning and polishing your pewter jewelry, let's start with the essentials.

What exactly is fine pewter?

Fine pewter is a silvery-gray tin-based alloy created from a minimum of 90% tin mixed with a sprinkling of silver, copper, bismuth, and antimony. Given the well-established health hazards associated with lead, it's worth noting that virtually all pewter jewelry produced in the United States is now entirely lead-free.

Fine pewter jewelry is also nickel-free, rendering it an ideal choice for individuals who are susceptible to allergic reactions or skin sensitivities triggered by nickel exposure. If you're one of those unlucky souls who breaks out in an itchy red rash at the mere mention of nickel, fine pewter is a reliable choice. You can trust it to keep your skin happy and your style on point.

What makes fine pewter the jeweler's choice?

On a global scale, pewter stands as the fourth most popular metal for crafting jewelry, trailing only behind gold, silver, and platinum. Fine pewter enjoys popularity in jewelry design primarily due to its affordability, durability, and hassle-free maintenance, offering a compelling alternative to sterling silver.

The versatility of pewter as a jewelry material is noteworthy; it can be polished to a smooth shine, chemically aged for an antique appearance, or skillfully brushed to leave behind an enchanting satin finish. Blending seamlessly with a range of styles, from vintage to modern, pewter's soft, muted sheen resonates with those seeking timeless charm and subtle beauty.

Ready, set, go...

Let's dive into some expert advice on cleaning, polishing, and storing your cherished pieces. Here's the nitty gritty...

How to clean your fine pewter jewelry.

Fine pewter jewelry boasts remarkable resistance to rust, corrosion, and tarnishing providing exceptional longevity when treated with care, often lasting for generations. Pewter doesn't tarnish like silver, which is a bonus, but it can still get a little dull over time. Cleaning pewter jewelry is a straightforward process, but it requires a gentle touch to prevent scratching or damaging the metal. Ready to tackle the dirt and grime? Let's do it!

  • Take it easy: To clean fine pewter jewelry, gently wash the surface using a soft cloth, a few drops of mild dish soap (I'm a big fan of good old blue Dawn dish detergent), and warm water. Avoid using stiff brushes or abrasive pads, as pewter is a delicate metal that can easily scratch.
  • Embrace the satin sheen: Fine pewter jewelry is distinct from sterling silver, often featuring a satin sheen rather than a mirrored finish. Polish your fine pewter jewelry sparingly and only if it appears to have lost its luster. You don't have to do it often, but when you do, oh boy, does it pay off! Roll up your sleeves and follow our natural polishing recipe below...
    1. Create a polishing paste by mixing 1/2 cup of white vinegar with 1/4 cup of white flour. For satin-finish pewter, add 1/2 teaspoon of salt to the mixture for a gentle abrasive texture.

    2. Use a soft cloth and a circular motion to gently apply the paste. No need for elbow grease – just a gentle rub will do. Sing your ABCs a time or two as if you are washing your hands. It adds a bit of fun!

    3. Allow the paste to sit on the pewter for approximately 30 minutes. This is the part where patience takes center stage - it's a bit like applying a face mask :)

    4. Rinse thoroughly with warm water and pat dry using a soft, lint-free cloth.
  • Commercial product caution: Keep in mind that commercial pewter polish is available but should be used sparingly. Whatever you do, avoid using brass or silver polish on pewter, as these cleaners can discolor your pewter jewelry. That would stink!

    How to protect and preserve your fine pewter jewelry.

    It's worth noting that many pewter pieces have endured through centuries. We're located in the historic town of Williamsburg, Virginia, so we've seen first-hand the original colonial pewter on display at the Governor's Palace that pre-dates the Patrick Henry and Thomas Jefferson era. Although the occupants of the colonial palace are LONG gone, we can testify that those pewter pieces are still looking as good as new!

    And so, from Colonial Williamsburg to you, here's 2 easy-peasy tried-and-true tips for storing your pewter jewelry to ensure its likewise longevity. 

    1. Shield from heat and chemicals: Safeguard your fine pewter jewelry by sheltering it from extreme heat and removing it when working with any harsh substances or chemicals such as household cleaning agents.

    2. Surround with cozy softness: Given the relatively soft nature of pewter, we recommend storing your fine pewter jewelry wrapped in a soft cloth while it is stashed away. 

      Ta-da! Big finish high-five!

      And there you have it...by following these simple cleaning, care, and storage guidelines, your fine pewter jewelry can become a lasting treasure, capable of withstanding the test of time and radiating its unique charm for years to come. Just like you! Now go be fabulous!

      Discover our craftsmanship: Explore our faith-filled collection of fine pewter necklaces, all proudly handcrafted in the USA. Each piece is a testament to the enduring beauty and craftsmanship of this remarkable metal. Joy, peace, & blessings to you friend!

    He Restores My Soul Fine Pewter Necklace     



    Tweet Share Pin It Email

    Also in What's new? Here's the latest from Clothed with Truth...

    Motherhood, Heartache, & Hope: A Faith-Filled Reflection for Mother's Day
    Motherhood, Heartache, & Hope: A Faith-Filled Reflection for Mother's Day

    Continue Reading

    Custom Engraved Handwriting Jewelry - Made in the USA
    The Art of Personalized Handwriting Jewelry: Your Guide to Creating a Timeless Keepsake

    Continue Reading

    The Lord's Prayer Sterling Silver Bangle Bracelet
    Why Christian Jewelry Is More Than Just an Accessory

    Continue Reading

    Customer Service
    • Search
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • FAQS
    • Shipping Info
    • Return Policy
    • Customer Reviews
    • Newsletter Sign Up
    • Coupon Codes
    • Blog
    • Privacy
    Let’s keep in touch!

    Get the behind-the-scenes scoop on the latest happenings here at Clothed with Truth. You can expect to hear from us on the 1st of each month. That's it, friend! We value your time and respect your inbox :) Your email address is secure and will not be shared with third parties. We look forward to welcoming you!

    1454
    Verified Reviews
    Wear it, Share it

    Clothed with Truth exists to shine the light of Christ through messages of joy, hope, and encouragement. Our mission is to inspire you to stand firm on God's promises, knowing that nothing can separate you from His unfailing love.


    © 2026 Clothed with Truth. | All Rights Reserved

    Visa Mastercard Discover American Express PayPal Apple Pay Google Pay
    Proud Member MJSA

    Let customers speak for us

    from 1457 reviews

    The world needs more of what Rhett and Deborah are bringing! The pure inspiration and presention of each piece brings comfort, peace, and light. I have ordered several items over the years and always feel that I am their only customer! That's how personal their gift feels. The items are the perfect combination of beauty and quality. It is my honor to be part of their circle of influence. Thank you, Rhett and Deborah, for offer so much of your selves and allow us to receive such wonderful gifts.

    Cheri
    05/11/2026

    Purchased a personalized bracelet for my Bestie. I was so pleased with the quality and craftsmanship. Rhett personally helped me perfect the inscription and my gift was a huge success. I am so thankful I found your site. You are truly a blessing and your products are exceptional. Customer service is second to none. Thanks, again for being a light and for sharing your gifts and talents with us. God bless you. I am grateful for being able to give such a lovely gift to my Bestie. The inscription was/is her life verse!

    Denise 😊🙌🏼

    DENISE L.
    09/06/2025
    *****  5 stars for Clothed With Truth

    Anyone out there with an small online business should order something from these fine folk as a lesson in how to get and keep a customer for life.  They have got customer service nailed 100%.  I had a few items that I needed ordered custom engraved for the kids of my sister who passed and Deborah and Rhett went out of their way to make my wishes a reality.  Communication was second to none.  Items arrived beautifully gift boxed and the recipients were in tears with delight at the finished products.  Order without thinking twice. Deborah and Rhett will make sure you are taken care of as if you were their only customer.  Thank you D and R and continued blessings for you and your business. Jon

    Jon B.
    09/26/2024
    Beautifully crafted

    5 stars is not enough!!! It was truly a pleasure dealing with this company. Ordering was easy and the time from ordering to receiving the item was extremely fast. The necklace was exquisite. You can tell they love what they do and really care about their customers. You will NOT be disappointed.

    Nicole W.
    08/10/2024
    It’s perfect!

    This company is wonderful. Service was great, got exactly what I ordered in a very timely fashion. Received email updates from the time I ordered until it arrived. Business with a personal touch! Ordered a second piece to give to a family member. Will definitely shop here again!

    Terri F.
    08/03/2024
    Necklace for my daughter's high school graduation

    I can't give enough stars for this shop!! Amazing customer service, great communication, and an obvious Christian based shop! I would 100% recommend just based on this! We received the necklace and it was beautifully wrapped and my daughter loved it. Great quality and beautiful! We will definitely be ordering for Clothed with Truth again! Thank you Deborah and Rhett!

    Melissa W.
    05/21/2024
    Value-Added

    I absolutely love this company! I have ordered from them three times. I love the attention to detail in the package that arrives. I have only ordered custom bracelets, but they are perfect every time. I love the handwritten sentiment on my order form. I love the option to make a custom item and the variety of fonts available. I love the extended size option, as well. The customer service is outstanding. I really just cannot say enough positive things about this company and their products. The speed in which I received my items was phenomenal, especially for a custom made item.

    Kay C.
    01/10/2024
    Fruit of the Spirit bracelet

    This company is the best company I have worked with in a long time. If could I would I would give them 100 stars. They were easy to work with, very kind and their main goal was to ensure I was satisfied with my bracelet. I did have to return my bracelet only because of my preference and they made the process so easy. They even called me to better understand what I wanted. It was an amazing experience. I would recommend this business to anyone and everyone. Thank you for displaying Christian principles in your business.

    Diane L.
    02/09/2023
    Exceptional Product & Customer Service

    Best customer service I have experienced in a while! I placed my order for a personalized dog tag with a Bible scripture and the very next day I got a phone call from them verifying the proof they emailed me. They wanted to make sure that I was going to love it before they sent it to me! So kind of them to go the extra step...and the jewelry is Sterling Silver and not cheap junk. I will definitely order from them again. This company operates with integrity and kindness!

    Lisa C.
    11/05/2022
    In Christ Alone

    Amazing his/hers cuff bracelets. Exceptional quality, truly blessed company and professional but old school owners. Would definitely recommend Clothedwithtruth to anyone looking for jewelry that displays their love for Christ. Amen!

    Derek T.
    04/19/2022
    Ageless piece

    This bracelet is perfect for the women and teens in my life. The packaging is beautiful, too, saving me wrapping time. Shipped quickly and I received a personal phone call to help me clarify and update my order. The best customer service and personal touches I’ve ever experienced.

    Sarah S.
    11/10/2021
    Exactly as promised!

    And in our world today we are so use to being disappointed it was breathe to my soul to receive these beautiful bracelets exactly as pictured and on time. While we know this isn’t always possible I particularly appreciated all the communication I received as the bracelets were in process and transport as well as the sweet note from the owners that was enclosed in the packaging. Thank you! You made me feel like I was getting a gift!

    Michelle H.
    11/08/2021
    Will make this my go-to for shopping for inspirational/faith based gifts

    I reached out to the owners because I needed some larger quantities for an event. I was thrilled with the prompt and professional response. Deborah really was able to help with different choices and personalization's that made our gifts extra special. I cannot say enough about dealing with people who truly care about their customers --it SHOWS! It is a pleasure doing business with them, and everything I ordered was so very true to picture and much better quality than I was expecting for the cost. Really exceeded expectations!! I would highly recommend them for church groups, bible studies and anybody needing a beautiful gift. THANK YOU!

    Jeanine O.
    07/22/2021

    What a breath of fresh air to have a small business with excellent customer service. The item I ordered was shipped promptly. The day I received the item was a particularly stressful day so when I opened the package, I was pleasantly surprised to receive the item in a beautiful bag/box with a handwritten thank you note on the receipt. It certainly brightened my day and reaffirmed that there are good people in this world. I will definitely be purchasing again from Clothed With Truth. Thank you!

    Jacqueline
    09/06/2020
    Wonderful Experience!

    What a special place to shop!! Clothed with Truth was so helpful to me in ordering a gift for a dear friend. They are top-notch in customer service and support, going out of their way to send my order so it was received on time. My friend loves her new bracelet, too! They also enclosed a special gift note! Thank you for a great experience and I will be back!

    Marcia B.
    07/07/2020